Peer Review Process

Dirassat Journal Economic Issue (DJEI) follows the Peer Review Guidelines according to,

  1. Directorate General of Scientific Research & Technological Development (DGSRTD) recommendations
  2. ASJP (Algerian Scientific Journal Platform) recommendations
  3. COPE with Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
  4. Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association

Peer-Reviewed Policies

  • The authors are requested to prepare the manuscript in good standards and verify the policies of DJEI before submitting it. We stand for critical evaluation, in-depth review, and the best way of communication of the research articles.
  • Once the article is confirmed for publication in our journal, authors should not submit the same article in any other journal, or they should withdraw their articles submitted to another journal.  Manuscripts with contents outside the scope will not be considered for review.
  • Two experts will review each article, recommended by the editorial board. If necessary, the article may undergo a few more reviews. Timely information about the review process will be communicated with authors when required.
  • The journal reserves the right to not accept the article, if it fails to follow the basic criteria of the journal’s policy. By referees report, the Editors-in-Chief can take a decision and notify the authors if their article is not accepted for publication.
  • Once the manuscript is submitted, it will be treated as confidential documents. Except with the author, no communications regarding the manuscript will is to other individuals or any publication agencies.
  • We will take all the necessary actions to prevent misuse of privileged information or ideas that are obtained through a peer review of submitted articles and will not be used for any competitive gain.
  • Editorial team/reviewers have the right to ask any supporting documents like (datasheets, informed consent, research approval letters, related ethical documents) at any time during the process.
  • The privacy and confidentiality of the peer reviewers and their work will be protected.

All published articles in the DJEI  are peered reviewed, and all manuscripts submitted follow the procedure outlined below.

Initial Manuscript Evaluation: All manuscripts submitted for publication in Journal are, firstly, evaluated by the Editorial Board Members. The editors employ double-blind reviewing, where both the referee and author remain anonymous throughout the process.

Referee Evaluation: After the initial evaluation, the manuscripts are sent to a minimum of two external referees for peer-review. If necessary, the number of referees can be increased by editors. The referees are chosen from the referee board according to their expertise. Referees are asked to evaluate the manuscript’s originality, methodology, contribution to the literature, presentation of results and support for the conclusions, and appropriate referencing of previous relevant studies. Referees might accept the manuscript, reject the manuscript, or might require a revision for style and content.

When a revision is required by the referee or referees, the author(s) is to consider the suggestions offered by the referees, and they should be sent back the revised version of a manuscript in one week. Revised manuscripts returned after one month are considered as a new submission (they have to wait to the next submission session), and the peer review process is started from the beginning. Referees may request more than one revision of a manuscript.

Possible decisions on a manuscript are:

  1. Accepted
  2. Accepted after minor revision
  3. Accepted after major revision
  4. Rejected

If minor revision is required, authors should return a revised version as soon as possible within one week.

Final EvaluationAfter favorable opinions of referees, the editorial board is made the final evaluation. The articles accepted for publication by the editorial are placed in an issue sequence.

Time of Peer Review ProcessThe journal aims to complete the all peer review process within four (4) to six (6)weeks. This time, however, may vary depending on the amount of revision work that needs to be completed before the manuscript is acceptable.